Guide
I won my GMC appeal. Why is the original decision still online?
Because the hearing was news and the judgment was not. The tribunal's decision was published, reported and copied in the months after the hearing. The High Court's judgment overturning it came a year or more later, was reported briefly if at all, and ranks nowhere. The GMC has removed the decision from your record. The internet has not noticed, and this is the cleanest delisting case there is.
In brief. Between 2019 and 2025 doctors brought more than a hundred appeals to the High Court against tribunal decisions. Eleven succeeded outright and eight more had the decision quashed and sent back for a fresh hearing. When a doctor wins outright, the GMC removes the original decision and any reference to the sanction from the register and shows a note for one year that a previous decision was overturned. The newspaper report of the original hearing, the copies of the quashed determination and the search results that show them are not affected by any of this until someone asks.
What the GMC does when you win
The GMC's publication policy sets out its routine approach. During the 28-day appeal window the fact of the window is published on your record, and if you appeal the register states that the sanction is not effective pending the outcome. If the court overturns all the tribunal's findings and the sanction, the original decision and references to the sanction are removed from your record and a note is shown for one year that a previous tribunal decision has been overturned on appeal. If the court quashes the decision and sends the case back, the original decision is removed from your record until the new hearing, with a similar one-year note. If your appeal is dismissed or withdrawn, a note to that effect is added to the top of the original decision. The MPTS hosts a post-appeal version of the record of determinations with a cover note explaining the outcome.
What nobody does
Nobody tells the regional paper that reported the allegations from the hearing notice, or the national title that reported the sanction. Nobody tells the commercial sites that copied the record of determinations while it was public. Nobody tells the search engines. A doctor who won in the High Court in 2024 can type their name into Google in 2026 and find the 2022 suspension headline first, the copied determination second, and the judgment that quashed both on page three, if it was reported at all.
The figures
The MPTS reports to Parliament record doctors' appeals by the year the tribunal hearing concluded. For hearings concluded in 2019, doctors brought 23 appeals, of which one succeeded and three were sent back. For 2020, 18 appeals, one successful, two sent back. For 2021, nine, two successful. For 2022, nine, three successful. For 2023, 21, three successful, one sent back. For 2024, 15, none successful, two sent back. For 2025, 18 appeals, one successful so far with seven still to be heard. Roughly one in ten appeals succeeds outright. Every one of those doctors was reported at the original hearing.
Why this is the strongest category
Every other delisting case argues that information has become out of date or no longer serves a purpose. This one argues that the information is wrong. The results describe a finding that a court has set aside and a sanction that no longer exists. The Court of Justice held in GC and Others v CNIL that where information about legal proceedings no longer corresponds to the current position, search results must at least be adjusted so that the overall picture reflects it. The ICO's criteria say information that has become inaccurate because it is out of date should normally be delisted, and that the ICO does not require delisting while a regulator is under a legal obligation to publish, an obligation the GMC has itself ended by removing the decision from your record. There is no public-protection purpose in a quashed finding.
The same applies, with less force, where the case was sent back and the fresh hearing produced a lesser outcome or no finding at all: the original coverage then describes a sanction that was replaced, and the results should reflect what replaced it.
What the court order does
In most cases the judgment or the court order is the whole argument. Attached to a delisting request it answers the public-interest question before it is asked, and attached to a request to the publisher it usually produces a correction, an update or a removal, because a report of a quashed decision without the quashing is inaccurate by omission and publishers know it. Copies of the determination on commercial sites are removed on the same basis. Cases in this category move quickly.
What you can do
Book a call and bring the judgment or the order, the links that come up for your name, and the dates. You will have a written answer within days on what can be delisted and removed, and in this category the answer is usually most of it.
Related
How long are MPTS decisions published for?
Can a GMC or MPTS decision be removed from Google?
The law, set out properly
Sources: GMC, Policy on publication and disclosure of fitness to practise information for doctors, August 2025, paragraphs 47 to 53. MPTS, Reports to Parliament 2021 to 2025, doctor appeals tables. GC and Others v CNIL (C-136/17). ICO, Search result delisting criteria.