After the GMCFree case review

Examples

Five cases, before and after

These are illustrative scenarios, not Repuserve client cases. They are built from the GMC's publication rules and the ICO's delisting criteria to show how the argument runs for the five situations doctors most often bring. No real doctor, case or publication is described.

Illustrative scenarios

Example one

A GP with an expired warning

The case
A GP accepted a warning from GMC case examiners in 2017 over record-keeping failures. No hearing, no restriction on practice. The warning came off the register in 2019.
What was still online in 2026
A regional newspaper's report of the warning, two syndicated copies of it on sister titles, and a "check a doctor" site carrying the text of the decision. All four on the first page of results for her name, above her practice's own website.
The argument
The GMC's own publication ended seven years ago. There is no legal obligation on anyone to publish it. The information is not current, the warning imposed no restriction, and she has practised without concern since. The public-protection purpose that justified publication in 2017 has been served and has ended.
The requests
Article 17 and 21 requests to Google and Bing for the four links, for searches of her name. A separate removal request to the aggregator site, which has no journalistic purpose and no legal basis of its own.
The typical outcome
Delisting for name searches accepted. The aggregator copy removed at source. The newspaper article remains on the publisher's site and can still be found by searching for the story rather than the doctor.
Time
Two to four months from instruction.

After: Dr [her name]

Illustrative

practice-website.nhs.uk

Dr [her name] – GP partner

Joined the practice in 2011 ...

gmc-uk.org › registration

Dr [her name] – medical register

Registered with a licence to practise. No current restrictions.

regional-newspaper.co.uk

GP given warning over record keeping

Delisted for name searches

Example two

A consultant whose suspension ended in 2013

The case
A hospital consultant was suspended for three months by a fitness to practise panel in 2013 for a failure of candour after a complication. He returned to practice, completed remediation and has held a substantive post since 2015. Under the GMC's policy a suspension of three months or less is published for ten years after it ends, so the register entry was removed in 2023.
What was still online
A national title's report of the hearing, a trade press piece, the tribunal determination copied in full onto two commercial sites, and a patient forum thread linking them. The determination copies rank above the national article because they carry his registration number and full name in the title.
The argument
Thirteen years since the events, ten since the sanction ended. The regulator has closed its own publication. He is in the same profession, which the ICO's criteria treat as a factor against, but the register itself now tells the public there is no restriction and the sanction was remediated to the regulator's satisfaction. The NT2 factors are all present: accepted findings, remediation, no repetition, no continuing need to warn anyone.
The requests
Delisting requests to Google, Bing, Yahoo and DuckDuckGo for all six links on name searches. Removal requests to the two commercial sites for the determination copies. A request to the forum operator for the thread.
The typical outcome
Determination copies removed at source, since the sites have no basis to process the data once the MPTS and GMC have stopped publishing it. National and trade press delisted for name searches, with the national title's refusal at first request taken to appeal. Forum thread removed by the operator.
Time
Three to five months, longer where a search engine refuses first time and the ICO is involved.

Example three

A doctor who was cleared

The case
A registrar faced a tribunal in 2022 on allegations arising from a complaint. The MPTS published the hearing notice and a summary of the allegations four weeks before the hearing. The tribunal found the facts not proved and her fitness to practise not impaired. Nothing was ever placed on her register entry.
What was still online
A regional paper's report headlined on the allegations, published on the first day of the hearing. No follow-up on the outcome. Two social media posts sharing the article. For a search of her name the allegation is the first result and the outcome appears nowhere.
The argument
The Court of Justice held in GC and Others v CNIL that where information about legal proceedings no longer corresponds to the current position, the search results must at least be adjusted so that the overall picture reflects it. Here they do not reflect it at all. The report is accurate about what was alleged and misleading about what happened, and there was never a sanction for any publication period to attach to.
The requests
Delisting requests on the grounds of inaccuracy by omission and lack of currency. A request to the publisher to update or remove the article, supported by the tribunal's determination. Requests to the platforms for the two posts.
The typical outcome
Publisher adds the outcome or removes the piece. Delisting accepted for name searches. Platforms remove the posts on the basis that they link to content the publisher has withdrawn or corrected.
Time
Usually at the shorter end of two to four months. Cleared cases move fastest because the public-interest argument is on the doctor's side from the start.

Example four

A health-only case

The case
A doctor agreed undertakings with the GMC solely on health grounds in 2019. Under the policy, health-only undertakings are removed from the register as soon as they end, and the tribunal decision is not published at all. The undertakings were revoked in 2021.
What was still online
A short news item that reported the undertakings and named the condition, and a professional networking post that discussed it. Both appear for a search of the doctor's name.
The argument
Health information is special category data. The ICO's criteria say it is more likely to require delisting when a search result reveals sensitive personal data, and its public-life guidance says that even for people with a role in public life, information about their health "should not normally appear in search results". The regulator itself chose not to publish this case beyond the life of the undertakings.
The requests
Delisting requests to all search engines. Removal request to the publisher on special category grounds, and to the platform for the post.
The typical outcome
Delisting accepted at first request. Publisher removes or anonymises the item. Post removed by the platform.
Time
Usually at the shorter end of two to four months.

Example five

A consultant who won on appeal

The case
A consultant was suspended for six months by a tribunal in 2021. He appealed to the High Court within the 28 days. Eighteen months later the court quashed the findings and the sanction in full. The GMC removed the decision from his record and, in line with its policy, showed a note for one year that a previous decision had been overturned on appeal.
What was still online
Two national reports and one regional report of the suspension, headlined on the findings. The original determination, copied onto two commercial sites before the appeal. A single trade press paragraph on the appeal outcome, on page three of results for his name. The suspension coverage still occupied the first four results in 2026.
The argument
The results describe a decision that no longer exists. GC and Others v CNIL requires search results about legal proceedings to reflect the current legal position, and the regulator itself has removed the decision. There is no public-protection purpose in a quashed finding, and the copies of the determination reproduce a document the MPTS no longer publishes in that form.
The requests
Delisting requests to all search engines, with the court order attached. Requests to the three publishers to remove or amend, supported by the judgment. Removal requests to the two commercial sites for the determination copies.
The typical outcome
Delisting accepted for name searches. Determination copies removed at source. Two of the three publishers amend or remove; the third is delisted for name searches and stays in its archive.
Time
Usually at the shorter end of two to four months. The court order does most of the work.

What these examples leave out. A doctor with an active sanction, an ongoing investigation or an erasure within the last ten years will usually be told at the review stage that delisting is not available yet, and given the date from which it will be. Repuserve does not take a fee for a case it does not expect to win.