The law
What gives a doctor the right to have a closed case delisted
Four things: a 2014 judgment of the Court of Justice, Articles 17 and 21 of the UK GDPR, the English High Court's decision in NT1 and NT2 v Google, and the ICO's published delisting criteria. This page sets each out as it applies to a doctor whose fitness to practise case has closed.
1 · The principle
Google Spain, 2014
In Google Spain v AEPD and Mario Costeja González (C-131/12) the Court of Justice of the European Union held that a search engine is a data controller in its own right, and that a person may require it to remove links from the results for a search of their name where the information is "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive in relation to those purposes and in the light of the time that has elapsed". The person does not have to show that the result is causing them harm.
The court said the person's rights override, as a rule, both the search engine's commercial interest and the general public's interest in finding the information, unless the person's role in public life justifies the interference. That last clause is where the argument about doctors is fought. The judgment remains part of UK law as retained case law.
2 · The statute
UK GDPR, Articles 17 and 21
Article 17 gives the right to erasure. The grounds that matter for a closed case are that the data are no longer necessary for the purpose for which they were processed (17(1)(a)), that the person has objected under Article 21 and there are no overriding legitimate grounds for the processing (17(1)(c)), and that the data have been unlawfully processed (17(1)(d)). Article 21 lets a person object to processing that relies on the controller's legitimate interests, which is the basis every search engine relies on, and requires the controller to stop unless it can show compelling legitimate grounds that override the person's interests.
Article 17(3) contains the exemptions. Processing that is necessary for exercising the right of freedom of expression and information is exempt, and so is processing required by a legal obligation or for a task in the public interest. Those two exemptions are why the publisher of a news article and the search engine that indexes it are in different positions, and why the GMC itself is in a different position again.
The publisher can rely on the journalism exemption in the Data Protection Act 2018, which disapplies the right to erasure where the controller reasonably believes publication is in the public interest. The High Court held in NT1 and NT2 that a search engine cannot: returning journalistic content in response to a name search is incidental to its commercial purpose and is not itself journalism. The GMC publishes under a statutory duty, but only for the periods its policy sets, and once a period ends there is no obligation left for anyone to rely on.
3 · The English authority
NT1 and NT2 v Google, 2018
Two businessmen with old criminal convictions asked the High Court to order Google to delist reports of them. Warby J granted one claim and refused the other. The reasons are the closest thing English law has to a checklist for a closed regulatory case.
Delisted NT2
- Pleaded guilty, expressed what the judge found to be genuine remorse.
- Conviction was spent. The court treated that as the point at which his privacy rights were engaged, and as a weighty factor.
- Now working in a different field, so the information was "of little if any relevance to anybody's assessment of his suitability" for what he does now.
- No evidence of any risk of repetition, and "no real need for anybody to be warned".
- Information had become "out of date, irrelevant and of no sufficient legitimate interest to users of Google Search".
Refused NT1
- Had not accepted guilt and showed no remorse.
- Sentence was long enough that, when it was passed, there was no expectation the conviction would ever be spent.
- Still in business in a field where honesty mattered to the public, so the information "retains sufficient relevance today".
- Had put out misleading material about himself online through a reputation firm, which the judge held against him.
- Harm complained of was largely to his business reputation, which the law protects less than private life.
Translated to a doctor: a case that has closed, a sanction the GMC itself no longer publishes, a clean record since, an honest account of what happened and no continuing purpose in warning patients are the facts that win. A recent case, an active sanction or a doctor who disputes the findings in public is a harder argument, and Repuserve will say so at the review stage rather than take the fee.
Google settled NT1's appeal before the Court of Appeal heard it, so the High Court judgment stands as the leading English authority. As far as we know there has been no reported English decision on delisting a professional regulatory outcome, which means each case is argued to the search engine on the criteria below, with the ICO as the route of complaint if the search engine refuses.
4 · The regulator's criteria
How the ICO decides a delisting complaint
The Information Commissioner publishes the criteria it applies when a search engine refuses a request and the person complains. Five of them decide a doctor's case.
| ICO criterion | What the ICO says | For a closed GMC case |
|---|---|---|
| Role in public life | "Members of the regulated professions can usually be considered to have a role in public life." The test is whether public access to the information "would protect them against improper public or professional conduct". | Cuts against delisting while the sanction is live and patients need to know. Once the GMC has decided the public no longer needs to see it, the protective purpose has gone. |
| Legal obligation to publish | The ICO "may not require de-listing of search results relating to the published content whilst the organisation is still under a legal obligation to make the information available". | The GMC's obligation ends with its publication period: two years for a warning, ten or fifteen for most sanctions, immediately for health-only orders. |
| Currency | "Normally we will require information that is not reasonably current or that has become inaccurate because it is out-of-date to be de-listed." | Coverage of an allegation that was not upheld, or of a sanction that has expired, is out of date on its face. |
| Sensitive data | "We are more likely to require delisting when a search result reveals sensitive personal data", which includes health. | Any case with a health element, and any coverage that reveals it, starts with this criterion in the doctor's favour. |
| Prejudice | Not required, "however, where there is evidence that the availability of a search result is causing prejudice to the individual, this would be a strong factor in favour of de-listing". | Lost appointments, locum agencies declining, patients raising it. Evidence of this is collected at the review stage. |
What delisting is not. It removes links from search results for your name. The pages remain where they are and can still be found by other searches or directly on the publisher's site. Removal at source, from the publisher or an aggregator, is a separate request on separate grounds, and Repuserve makes those too where the grounds exist.
One more point
Spent convictions and the GMC
Doctors are listed in the Exceptions Order to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, which means a spent conviction still has to be declared to the GMC and the GMC's guidance says the Exceptions Order does not affect fitness to practise disclosure. Delisting changes none of that. It is a right against the search engine, not against the regulator, and Repuserve will not take on any case on the basis that it alters what a doctor must disclose.
Sources: Google Spain v AEPD (C-131/12), 13 May 2014, paragraphs 93 to 99. UK GDPR Articles 6(1)(f), 17 and 21, legislation.gov.uk. Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 2, Part 5, paragraph 26. NT1 and NT2 v Google LLC [2018] EWHC 799 (QB), paragraphs 100, 166, 170 and 223. ICO, Search result delisting criteria. Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exceptions) Order 1975, Schedule 1, Part I. GMC, Guidance on reporting convictions and regulatory proceedings, paragraph 11.